Picking Your Employee of the Month with the Right Criteria


Picking employee of the month is not a popularity contest. Instead, look at your company’s objectives and use them as selection criteria. As a result, your employee of the month program skyrockets your results, inspires your employees, and turns your clients into raving fans.

How do you measure success?

Start by setting up your winner selection criteria to use as a guideline, because criteria is one of the biggest factors that will affect the success of your program.

use specific criteria for picking employee of the month

Above all, selecting your monthly winner should never be a popularity contest. In our experience, this makes your program ineffective and ruins the return on your investment. Allowing your staff to vote for their favorite employee is the one of the biggest reasons we see employee recognition programs fail, because it ignores actual job performance.

Criteria is king when picking employee of the month

Your decision for a monthly winner should be based on specific criteria. That way, it is always based on measurable objectives.

As you set up your program, talk with your EC about what is important to you as a manager and to the success of your business. Think about the kinds of actions you want to reinforce in your workplace. Use those things as the basis for your criteria and winner selection.

Remember: It’s not a popularity contest.

Company KPI

The good news is you’re probably already tracking much of what you need as part of your company metrics and KPI. Sales, time & attendance, add-ons & up-sells, and specific company initiatives are all usually tracked by internal systems. It can be as easy as pulling up a report at the end of the month so you can see who had the highest performance.

If that’s not an option, ask your Engagement Coach for ideas. MyEmployees has worked with thousands of leaders in dozens of industries for over 30 years. As a result, we’ve learned best practices from some of the world’s biggest brands. Your EC is happy to share that knowledge with you.

Tips for picking employee of the month from industry insiders

Check out some of the most popular criteria we see our clients use in a variety of industries. We pulled the best of the best from managers in over a half dozen industries to come up with 24 Insider Secrets That Improve Employee Recognition Success (…actually, it turned out to be even more than 24!).

Tips for picking employee of the month from industry insiders

Find your industry first, and the check out the whole video for even more ideas on what other industries use when picking employee of the month.

Share the goals with your team

Finally, let your employees know exactly what is expected of them and what it takes to win. No one hits a target they can’t see. Your employees will be most productive when they know specifically what it takes to win.

Clarity is key. Make sure everything is clearly communicated so there can be no ambiguity. This goes a long way toward preventing any question as to why someone won. When everyone knows exactly what it takes, there can be no argument.

Check out more posts from the
MyEmployees Learning Center


Recognition ABC’s

Peep these recognition tips and tricks and get rolling with employee recognition. Read more here.

Leadership Training

Become a top 10% manager in your industry and get the promotion you’ve always dreamed of with some of the tips and training you’ll find HERE.

Customer Stories

Get inspired by some of our most successful customers HERE.

Our Culture

Yes, we’re unique. Learn all about the fun and adventures that make us who we are HERE.

Connect with us today!

800.489.0230

Need recognition at your location?